Under-eye patches are one of the fastest ways to reduce puffiness and wake up tired skin. But not all formulas are created equal. We compared two popular products available on Amazon Canada — one budget-friendly, one premium — to help you decide which suits your needs.
| Ingredient | Effect |
|---|---|
| Caffeine (Peter Thomas Roth) | Vasoconstrictor; helps reduce puffiness more prominently |
| Cucumber Extract (Peter Thomas Roth) | Soothing, antioxidant benefits |
| Hydrogel Base (Both) | Hydrates and plumps fine lines temporarily |
| Fragrance-free (Grace & Stella) | Lower risk of irritation for sensitive skin |
The Peter Thomas Roth formula includes botanical extracts and caffeine — both shown to support depuffing beyond hydration alone. Grace & Stella’s formula focuses on hydration and comfort, which works well but lacks those advanced actives.
Comfort & Sensitivity
-
Grace & Stella: Excellent for sensitive skin due to the absence of fragrance and strong botanicals. No irritation reported in most user feedback.
-
Peter Thomas Roth: Light cucumber scent and active botanicals can be a slight irritant for extremely reactive skin, though this is uncommon.
For sensitive users, Grace & Stella may feel gentler over repeated use.
How they feel on the skin
Grace & Stella: Softer gel texture, adheres well, minimal residue. Skin feels smooth and primed for makeup.
Peter Thomas Roth: Slightly firmer gel with cooler initial sensation — especially if pre-chilled. Leaves a subtle tightening feel post-use.
Price per patch: What you’re paying for
A key difference is cost efficiency:
-
Grace & Stella: Typically falls between $0.50–$1.00 per patch depending on pack size and seller deals on Amazon Canada. It’s one of the more budget-friendly options with solid performance for the price.
-
Peter Thomas Roth: Premium positioning leads to $2.25–$3.50 per patch (approx). The higher cost reflects stronger actives and a reputation backed by a dermatology-oriented brand.
If you’re patching daily or gifting multiple sets, Grace & Stella is easier on the wallet. But if you want maximum depuffing effect on a single use, the premium price of Peter Thomas Roth often correlates with a more pronounced outcome.
Who should choose which?
Choose Grace & Stella if:
-
You want a gentle, fragrance-free formula
-
Value is a priority
-
You’re gifting or using regularly
-
You have sensitive skin
Choose Peter Thomas Roth if:
-
Puffiness is persistent or pronounced
-
You want stronger active ingredients like caffeine and botanicals
-
Skin tightening and antioxidant support matter
-
Price isn’t your primary concern
Accgo Verdict
For everyday use: Grace & Stella wins with practical performance and budget-friendly pricing.
For maximum de-puffing and visible “wow” effect: Peter Thomas Roth edges ahead thanks to superior actives.
Both deliver hydration and refresh the eye area, but your choice should depend on whether you’re prioritizing cost-efficiency or enhanced performance.
By Jessica Borga. Accgo doesn’t review products. It explains whether living with them actually makes life easier—especially in Canada.
